Technical SEO Audit: How to Check If Your Website Has Hidden Problems

Technical SEO issues are sneaky because they don’t show up when you’re just browsing your own site normally — but they can quietly cap how well even great content ranks. Here’s how to audit your site’s technical health, step by step.

Step 1: Check Crawlability

Search engines can only rank pages they can actually access and read. Check for:

  • robots.txt errors — make sure you’re not accidentally blocking search engines from important pages
  • Broken internal links — dead links waste crawl budget and hurt user experience
  • Orphan pages — pages with no internal links pointing to them are much harder for search engines to discover

Step 2: Confirm Indexability

Being crawlable doesn’t guarantee a page is indexed. In Google Search Console, check the Coverage/Indexing report for:

  • Pages marked “Excluded” that should be indexed
  • Accidental noindex tags left on important pages (common after a site migration or theme change)
  • Duplicate content issues where Google has chosen a different canonical version than you intended

Step 3: Audit Site Speed

Page speed affects both rankings and user experience directly. Use Google PageSpeed Insights or a similar tool to check:

  • Largest Contentful Paint (LCP) — how fast your main content loads
  • Interaction to Next Paint (INP) — how responsive your page feels to user input
  • Cumulative Layout Shift (CLS) — whether elements jump around as the page loads

These three make up Google’s Core Web Vitals, and poor scores can hold back rankings even when content quality is strong.

Step 4: Check Mobile Usability

Google primarily uses the mobile version of your site for ranking (mobile-first indexing), so mobile issues directly affect your entire site’s performance, not just mobile search results specifically. Check for:

  • Text that’s too small to read without zooming
  • Buttons or links too close together to tap accurately
  • Content that requires horizontal scrolling

Step 5: Review Your XML Sitemap

  • Confirm your sitemap includes all important pages and excludes ones you don’t want indexed
  • Submit it through Google Search Console if you haven’t already
  • Check for broken or redirected URLs listed inside it — these send mixed signals to search engines

Step 6: Check for Duplicate Content

Duplicate or near-duplicate content confuses search engines about which version to rank, often diluting rankings across both. Common causes include:

  • URL parameters creating multiple versions of the same page
  • HTTP and HTTPS versions both being indexed
  • www and non-www versions both being live and indexed

Fix this with proper canonical tags and consistent redirects.

Step 7: Audit HTTPS and Security

  • Confirm your entire site runs on HTTPS, not just specific pages
  • Check for mixed content warnings (HTTP resources loading on an HTTPS page)
  • An invalid or expired SSL certificate can actively hurt trust signals and rankings

Step 8: Check Structured Data for Errors

Use Google’s Rich Results Test to confirm any schema markup on your site is implemented correctly — broken schema can prevent rich snippets from appearing, or in some cases cause manual actions if implemented deceptively.

Tools to Run This Audit

  • Google Search Console — free, essential, shows real indexing and performance data directly from Google
  • Google PageSpeed Insights — free Core Web Vitals testing
  • Screaming Frog (free tier available) — crawls your site like a search engine would, surfacing broken links, redirect chains, and missing metadata at scale

Final Takeaway

Technical SEO problems are easy to miss because they’re invisible during normal browsing — but they quietly cap your site’s ranking potential regardless of how good your content is. Running through this audit quarterly catches most issues before they meaningfully affect traffic.

Leave a Comment